Sunday, February 11, 2018

My Amazon GO Store Experience

(This post started as a LinkedIn.com update, but I quickly ran out of character space, so here's my full review).

UPDATE for 2/13/2018:

  • I stopped by GO on my way into work and picked up a Blazing Bagels breakfast sandwich and protein fruit drink. Total time in-store: 1:10 min. 

ORIGINAL POST:
On Friday (2/9), I stepped out of my new Belltown office for lunch and an experiment: my goal was to successfully navigate the new Amazon GO store in Seattle and emerge with a meal.

Before going any further, I need to recognize the amount of work that obviously went into getting the venture up and running. Creating the world's first cashier-less store for a non-membership store was clearly no easy feat. All of the Amazon engineers, product managers, and user experience experts should be commended for their great work.

I tackled this experiment wearing my user experience hat, which is a blend of a decade of writing for broadcast news, another 2 decades working in digital, and insights gleaned from various experience experts, not to mention Donald Norman's "The Design of Everyday Things."

The first requirement of using the store is to download the Amazon GO app, for which you need an Amazon account. I subscribe to Prime so all my account information; name, address, purchase history, debit card, etc, is on file with Amazon. The app has a really good primer on what to expect with the experience: launch the app and scan your phone upon entry in the store, take what you want, return what you don't want, don't take objects off the shelves for others, and walk out when you are done. Easy enough.

Amazon stations employees at the entrance to hand out shopping bags. Having not experienced it before, I wondered if the bags were somehow required for the experience. Were they tagged with sensors? No, as it turns out. Just a convenience. Right outside the store was a line of stanchions--not in use that day--which is kind of funny; you may have to wait in line to enter the store that doesn't have checkout lines. This was my first indicator that Seattle has a new tourist destination.

So upon entering the store, I was immediately struck by the number of people who were shooting video and taking pictures, rather than shopping. It reminded me of Times Square in NYC with people spending more time getting a photo than watching where they are walking. The amateur photographers were the second indicator that this is a new tourism "must do" in Seattle.


So, with my phone in one hand and shopping bag in the other, I conducted tour of the store perimeter. This didn't take long because it isn't a big store. But it is new and clean and nice. Think of it as a high-end convenience store. A Better Bodega. A Super 7-11. Or a Half-sized Whole Foods. The offerings include a wide-selection of pre-made sandwiches and meals, alcohol, sides, and various other foods. I went with an Italian Grinder and bag of Half-pops. Along the way, I experimented with removing items from the shelves and returning them to see if the app would show the changes, but nothing ever appeared on the app to indicate that I have made any selections, which led me to wonder if I was doing it correctly. I was, in fact, and had to rely on my memory of the app demo and my own sense of right and wrong to get through this first time. I would recommend an improvement to the app in a future release that displayed customer selections in real-time.
A ceiling of sensors
After wandering the store a little more, I decided to test my comfort with walking out the door without the cash register experience. It was... weird. No alarms went off, expect for what was programmed into my mind through a half-decade of commerce. It was when the French TV news crew approached me outside the store that I suddenly felt like that this was a big Candid Camera joke.

But no joke, they were interviewing all sorts of customers. They did have to show me where to find the record of my transaction in the app. Again, this is a natural opportunity for the app to give me a "transaction complete" alert once I'm free and clear of the store. As it was, the receipt was emailed an hour after my visit. Immediate gratification for acknowledgement of the transaction will be needed for this to really take off.

So if there's a word I would use to describe this experience, it would be "novelty." This is not to denigrate in any way all the work that went into the store, but it introduces a new way to shop that is one-of-a-kind, and it feels very much like a pilot of what could be a larger and more immersive experience.

So how was the lunch? It was OK. I don't think the grinder was made by someone who ever had a real East Coast grinder; a few slices of salami does not a grinder make. But I'm going back again, you can be sure. I'll try other foods and bring friends and family.

What else would you do with a tourist attraction?

Tuesday, January 23, 2018

The Left and Right News Spectrum

In 1993, I was working as a writer at WCIX in Miami. South Florida was still recovering from Hurricane Andrew's destruction the previous August and there was never a shortage of post-storm stories. South Florida news stations loved any kind of sensational story back then--flash-n-trash always ran at the top of the newscast--but it was a real surprise when the 6pm producer ran a wire story about Stephen Cook accusing Chicago's Cardinal Joseph Bernardin of sexual molestation.

This was the time of repressed memories. Patients would undergo hypnosis and suddenly remember events from their past. Even if that event never happened. This was the case with Cook, who claimed to have a repressed memory uncovered through hypnosis of being molested by Bernardin. Only it never happened.

Cook was encouraged to make accusations against Bernardin by a third party as way to get money from the Church. Only 2 people knew this when the story came out; Cook and the third party.

When the story broke, the WCIX news producer declared that she "hated the Catholic Church" and led the newscast with it: lead story with an edited video segment. Her comment has stayed with me for three decades.

About six weeks later, Cook announced the truth; that he'd lied and Bernardin was innocent. I looked to the producer for her response. It was this: the story would run as a 20-second reader leading into sports and weather. And no regrets for having run the original story.

It was at this point that I lost interest in my news career. It was clear that any sense of objectivity was dead. And being objective was a goal of the highest ideals that we were taught in our college journalism classes.

Funny thing about the idea of journalistic objectivity--it was a marketing ploy publishers in the early 20th century used to sell newspapers. Before this time, newspapers were roundly viewed as subjective publications. You read a newspaper, or pamphlet, because it reinforced your viewpoints on the world. Yellow journalism was the norm and two of the biggest players were Joseph Pulitzer's New York World and William Randolph Hearst's New York Journal.

An example of New York Journal's famous yellow journalism. 
Seems like we are living through a second coming of yellow journalism. Biases lead news judgement and no one is willing to admit they are skewed.

CNN is overwhelmingly liberal and has a justifiable axe to grind against Trump. Fox News is overwhelmingly Trump friendly and ignores 99% of the stories critical to our current Administration. InfoWars isn't news and MSNBC breathlessly delivers every story as melodrama. And I haven't even touched on fake news.

I find its best to keep news sources in rotation, moving among the outlets and compiling truth from various sources. But which ones to trust?

There are a few efforts on the interwebs for scoring the major news outlets on their political biases, but even those evaluations are skewed. What I find most interesting is that NPR is now considered to be fairly mainstream. It used to be far left.

If you want to have your opinions reinforced, then by all means, rely on the sources with whom you agree. If you want to be challenged, read material from the neutral zone of news. Or even the opposing views.

Here are a few sources who have categorized the various news outlets. Not all agree, but they have plenty of similarities.